As far as I'm concerned if it doesn't have tits, ass and puss puss, it's not anthro. You could say my tastes are pretty - straight - forward.
One of the older ones I never went through with putting out there could be summarized like this.
> be guy
> fall off ferry/cruiseship with nobody noticing
> get saved by big anthro lapras and gyarados
> they keep him in cave under Island in the middle of nowhere on the sea
> lapras is timid, gyarados overbearing and has little self-control
> they feed him and their origin sickles through
> ran away from master
> turns out running away from the person that fucks and feeds you is a bad idea if you're a sexually insatiable freakshow
> gyarados wants to just hold him down and roughly use him as fucktoy
> lapras convinces her to stop that and seduce him over time
> gets too freaked out over her first advances, as he has no idea what the fuck is going on and what the two of them are
> wakes up with her sleeping with an arm wrapped around him like a plushie or pet
> doesnt even say a thing when she catches him having a hard-on
> starts reading all the signs of attraction/sexual frustration
> starts realizing that this is all for real
> sex scene with back-and-forth subtle signals guiding/edging each other on
> at end lapras offers the obvious deal
> they bring him back to the mainland but only if he fucks the gyarados once too
> [insert degenerate fetish of choice]
> when it's done, is transported back to mainlandPost too long. Click here to view the full text.